Welcome! The Northampton Bridge Club welcomes anyone who wishes to play duplicate bridge. Online open pair games are played on https://www.bridgebase.com/ at 7:00PM on Tuesdays and Thursdays; In-person games are played @1:00PM at the Christ United Methodist Church, 271 Rock Hill Road (Route 66) in Northampton.

If you need a partner, look HERE first, or contact Philippe at phgalaski@gmail.com for help.

HELP...      RESULTS     BridgeWhiz      PHOTOS      STORIES

Saturday, January 5, 2008

Win the Trick or Hold Up?
An Eternal Bridge Question
by Jim Kaplan

Sitting West, you see declarer lead a card toward the following Dummy suit:

K Q 10 5 4

Should you go up with the ace from your hand?

This familiar scenario repeated itself at the Northampton Bridge Club on December 11. East was dealing, with no one vulnerable:

NORTH
S J 6
H Q 10 6 5
D K Q 10 5 4
C A 10
WEST EAST
S 5 4 2 S 7 3
H A 9 3 H K 8 4
D A 8 7 6 D J 3 2
C K 8 6 C Q 9 7 5 2
SOUTH
S A K Q 10 9 8
H J 7 2
D 9
C J 4 3

The bidding proceeded as follows:

East South West North
Pass 1S Pass 2D
Pass 2S Pass 4S
All Pass

Opening lead: spade 2

Declarer drew two rounds of trump and led the diamond 9. Figuring South held a singleton, West went up with the ace and led a trump. Alas, South threw two club losers and two hearts on diamond winners and made five for a shared top.

If West holds off on diamonds, declarer wins the first diamond trick but can’t throw clubs or hearts on diamond winners. Instead, South loses a club and two hearts, making four for a high-middle board.

That’s not to say you should never go up with the ace when you see the king-queen on the board. Play the ace when it’s the setting trick or if you’re sure that partner earlier led a singleton and trumps are still out. By in large, though, taking one defensive trick while establishing two offensive ones isn’t a good idea.

No comments: